UNC Shows Grit Against Notre Dame, But the Same Flaws Keep Costing Them

North Carolina came into Saturday's game as a 21-point underdog against No. 3 Notre Dame. Most fans braced for a blowout. Instead, they got something more frustrating: proof that the Tar Heels can hang with the best, followed by the same mistakes that keep them from finishing the job.

The final score read 37-26 in favor of the Fighting Irish, but the game felt closer than that. UNC (2-2, 0-1 ACC) actually led 7-0 after a 74-yard opening drive capped by a Billy Edwards touchdown pass to Shamar Easter. Notre Dame (5-0) responded with three straight scoring possessions, but the Tar Heels kept clawing back, even returning the second-half kickoff 98 yards for a score.

In the end, turnovers and a porous run defense told the story. Here are the five biggest takeaways from a loss that stings more than most.

Turnovers turned a winnable game into a loss

Great teams punish mistakes, and Notre Dame did exactly that. Edwards threw two first-half interceptions, and both led directly to Fighting Irish touchdowns. The first pick set up a 12-yard scoring pass from CJ Carr to Jaden Greathouse. The second led to a 39-yard deep ball to Jordan Faison.

Take those two turnovers away, and UNC is staring at a potential upset. That's the frustrating part for a team that clearly has the talent to compete.

UNC can play with anyone, but can't close the deal

There's a pattern emerging. The Tar Heels responded to every Notre Dame punch, keeping the deficit within reach for most of the afternoon. But late in the game, the Fighting Irish leaned on their power run game and simply wore UNC down.

North Carolina has the pieces to beat top-tier opponents. The gap between competing and winning comes down to eliminating early mistakes and holding up defensively in the fourth quarter. Until that changes, moral victories will keep piling up without actual ones.

The run defense remains a serious problem

If there's a blueprint for beating UNC, it's simple: run the ball. Notre Dame racked up a season-high 241 rushing yards, led by Jonaz Walton's 120. Nolan James added 65, and Aneyas Williams chipped in 42.

This isn't a one-game issue. Clemson ran for 186 yards in September. TCU's Jeremy Payne totaled 142. Next up is Pitt, where five different players have rushing touchdowns this season. If the Tar Heels can't stop the run in Pennsylvania, a third straight loss is looking likely.

The receiving corps is a genuine strength

While the defense struggled, UNC's pass-catchers showed why they're the heart of this offense. Easter caught his first career touchdown. Jelani Thurman continued to prove he's a top-tier tight end with two more scores. And Jordan Shipp broke out with a career-high 109 receiving yards.

Even with Edwards' early interceptions, the Tar Heels can count on almost anyone in the passing game to make a play. That depth is a real asset moving forward.

A missing run game puts too much pressure on Edwards

UNC's backfield is deep on paper, with Benjamin Hall, Demon June, and Jaylen McGill all capable of leading the charge. But on Saturday, that trio combined with Edwards for just 77 yards on 23 carries.

Without a ground game, the offense becomes one-dimensional, forcing Edwards to carry the load. He delivered with three touchdowns, but that's not a sustainable formula. The Tar Heels need to establish the run to unlock their play-action passing game and keep defenses honest.

What's next for the Tar Heels?

UNC travels to face Pitt next, and the matchup doesn't look favorable given the run defense issues. The Panthers have a multi-headed rushing attack, and if the Tar Heels can't fix their tackling and gap discipline, it could be a long afternoon.

The talent is there. The execution isn't consistent enough yet. For a team that clearly believes it belongs with the nation's best, the next step is proving it by finishing games, not just competing in them.

Follow us @TarHeelsWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of North Carolina Tar Heels news, notes and opinions.